Recycling - Does it work
April 17th, 2007 by Colin JamiesonHave you ever considered why we recycle, what are we attempting to acheive? Are we trying to save the planet, slow down the flow of unwanted packaging and artefacts to land-fill, or a combination of all of these?
I thought it would be useful to stimulate the debate in Christchurch as we are contemplating how to proceed with the next phase of recycling in the borough and throughout the county.
Government targets are weight based so high density items such as glass or paper take precedence over plastic. taking paper, cardboard and green waste, which are all biodegradeable to be recycled is very laudible, but what about the residuals that go to landfill; if, and it is a big if all the above was recycled, then the landfills would comprise plastic. Is that right? Turn the argument around, put biodegradeables to landfill and recycle the plastics would that be better for the future?
We currently send lorries around the borough, collecting about 20% of the permitted recyclables (a requirement by Dorset County Council and the contract they have with SITA). The vehicles in my opinion (untested scientifically) produce more pollution than the environmental savings derived from the recycling process. So what are the gains?
Would it be better to collect efficiently and then separate the rubbish into constituent components, thus minimising the pollution effect of the process?
Do you think that all our collected garden waste should be sent for recycling? It currently goes to landfill!
I could go on, but am seeking an indication of feeling before developing the various options available. But before I finish, a final point - Do you feel it is a good thing for trade waste to be collected with domestic waste and disposed of in the same process? The council has not mandate for doing this, but taking a holistic view, there is only one land and one set of roads!
Colin P Jamieson